The Genesis of Volatility-Based ETPs

The concept of volatility as a tradable asset class gained traction in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis. Investors, scarred by the market’s violent swings, sought ways to hedge against future turbulence or capitalize on it. This demand led to the creation of volatility-based ETPs, which track indexes like the VIX (CBOE Volatility Index), often referred to as the market’s fear gauge.

These products were initially designed as short-term trading vehicles for institutional investors. However, their accessibility through exchange-traded formats soon attracted a broader audience, including retail investors. The promise of diversification and potential for outsized returns during market downturns made volatility-based ETPs an enticing proposition for those looking to enhance their portfolio strategies.

Understanding the Mechanics

At their core, volatility-based ETPs aim to provide exposure to market volatility without directly holding the underlying assets. Most of these products use futures contracts on volatility indexes to achieve their objectives. The VIX, for instance, measures the market’s expectation of 30-day volatility implied by S&P 500 index options.

The use of futures introduces complexities such as contango and backwardation – terms describing the relationship between spot and futures prices. In contango, which is more common, futures prices are higher than spot prices, leading to a phenomenon called negative roll yield. This can erode returns over time, even if the underlying index remains flat.

Types of Volatility-Based ETPs

Investors can choose from several types of volatility-based ETPs, each with its own risk-return profile:

1. Long Volatility ETPs: These products aim to profit from increases in market volatility. They tend to perform well during market crashes but may suffer during prolonged periods of calm.

2. Inverse Volatility ETPs: Designed to benefit from decreases in volatility, these products can generate strong returns in bull markets but face significant risks during volatility spikes.

3. Leveraged Volatility ETPs: These offer amplified exposure to volatility movements, both long and short, magnifying potential gains and losses.

4. Dynamic Volatility ETPs: Some products employ more complex strategies, adjusting their exposure based on market conditions or trends.

Risk Management and Portfolio Applications

Incorporating volatility-based ETPs into a portfolio requires a nuanced approach to risk management. These products can serve various functions, from hedging against market downturns to seeking alpha in specific market conditions. However, their behavior can be counterintuitive and potentially destructive if misunderstood.

One common application is using long volatility ETPs as a form of portfolio insurance. During periods of market stress, these products tend to spike in value, potentially offsetting losses in other parts of the portfolio. Conversely, some investors use inverse volatility ETPs to generate income during low-volatility periods, akin to selling insurance.

Advanced strategies might involve pairs trading between different volatility products or using them in conjunction with options strategies. The key is to understand the precise exposure each product provides and how it fits within the broader investment thesis.

Pitfalls and Cautionary Tales

The history of volatility-based ETPs is not without its cautionary tales. Perhaps the most notorious example is the collapse of XIV, an inverse volatility ETP, in February 2018. A sudden spike in volatility led to catastrophic losses, ultimately resulting in the product’s termination. This event underscored the potential for extreme losses and the importance of understanding the inherent risks.

Other pitfalls include the erosion of value over time due to the roll cost in futures-based products, especially in contango environments. Investors must also be wary of the tracking error between these products and the underlying volatility indexes, particularly over longer holding periods.

Moreover, the complex nature of these products can lead to misuse. They are often more suitable for short-term trading rather than long-term holding, a distinction not always clear to novice investors attracted by past performance or the allure of volatility as an asset class.

---

Essential Insights for Volatility ETP Investors

• Always read the prospectus carefully to understand the product’s structure and risks

• Monitor the term structure of VIX futures to anticipate potential roll costs

• Be prepared for significant price swings, especially during market turbulence

• Consider using stop-loss orders to manage downside risk

• Regularly rebalance positions to maintain desired exposure levels

• Understand the impact of leverage and daily resets on long-term performance

• Stay informed about regulatory changes that may affect these products

---

As the financial markets continue to evolve, volatility-based ETPs remain a double-edged sword – offering unique opportunities while posing substantial risks. Their complexity demands a level of sophistication and ongoing education from investors. While they can be powerful tools in the right hands, they require constant vigilance and a deep understanding of market dynamics.

For those willing to invest the time and effort to master these intricate products, volatility-based ETPs open up new avenues for portfolio management and alpha generation. However, they are not suitable for everyone, and even experienced investors must approach them with caution. As with any sophisticated financial instrument, the key lies in thorough research, disciplined risk management, and a clear-eyed assessment of one’s investment goals and risk tolerance.